Morgan Stanley’s Bullish Bet on Tapestry: Luxury’s Tariff-Proof Bubble?
Yo, let’s talk about that shiny new upgrade Morgan Stanley just slapped on Tapestry Inc. (NYSE: TPR)—bumping it from “meh” to “overweight” with a $90 price target. *Cue the confetti cannons.* But hold up, before we all start daydreaming about Coach handbags funding our retirement, let’s poke this bubble with a stick. Because if there’s one thing we’ve learned from 2008, it’s that Wall Street’s love letters often come with fine print.
—
1. Earnings Momentum: A Mirage or a Money Printer?
Morgan Stanley’s gushing over Tapestry’s “robust earnings momentum,” citing a gross margin expansion to *74.77%* and a current ratio of 1.58. *Damn.* That’s tighter than a Brooklyn loft’s square footage. But here’s the kicker: excluding Japan, growth was “significant.” Translation: one shaky market away from a “whoopsie” moment. And let’s not forget, gross margins this high in luxury retail? Either Tapestry’s selling gold-plated totes, or someone’s playing accounting Jenga.
Sure, 17 straight years of dividends sound cozy, but remember—dividends are like rooftop cocktails: refreshing until the storm hits. With global demand wobbling like a drunk tourist in Times Square, how long can those margins stay sky-high? *Bubble trap alert.*
—
2. Brand Resilience: Luxury’s Immunity Myth
Morgan Stanley’s swooning over Coach, Kate Spade, and Stuart Weitzman’s “resilience” in a “challenging macroeconomic environment.” *Cute.* Luxury brands love to cosplay as recession-proof, but let’s get real: when rent’s due, even the 1% swap Birkins for bulk ramen.
The report highlights “improved brand performance,” but dig deeper: how much of that growth is fueled by markdowns and outlet malls? (Spoiler: *a lot.*) And Kate Spade’s post-acquisition glow-up? Let’s just say it’s easier to rebrand a purse than to reinvent consumer spending.
Oh, and those tariffs? Tapestry’s “resilience” is less about genius strategy and more about passing costs to you, the sucker—sorry, *valued customer.* Next time you see a $400 Coach wallet, ask yourself: *Is this leather, or just inflation in disguise?*
—
3. Strategic Moves: Dodging Bullets or Just Debt?
The Capri merger’s collapse got Morgan Stanley all hot and bothered, calling it “credit positive.” Translation: Tapestry dodged a debt grenade. Smart? Absolutely. But let’s not confuse survival with supremacy. Avoiding a bad deal isn’t the same as scoring a win—it’s like bragging you didn’t swipe right on a scammer.
And that “leverage below 2x” target? Admirable, but remember: leverage is a silent killer. Ask anyone who survived the housing crash (*cough* yours truly). Tapestry’s playing it safe now, but in a sector where “luxury” means “markup,” one bad quarter could turn those ratios into a horror show.
—
The Bottom Line
Morgan Stanley’s upgrade isn’t *wrong*—it’s just… optimistic. Tapestry’s got solid numbers, sure, but luxury retail’s a game of musical chairs, and the music’s slowing. That $90 target? Could be a bullseye, or just another dart thrown after three martinis.
So here’s my take: if you’re buying Tapestry, do it for the dividends, not the daydreams. And maybe—just maybe—save some cash for those clearance-rack Stuart Weitzmans. *Because even bubble poppers need cute shoes.* 砰.
